Winning the green card lottery is supposed to be the lucky break of a lifetime. For thousands of DV-2021 diversity visa winners, it turned into a legal nightmare instead. Pandemic travel bans, shuttered consulates, and a hard statutory deadline collided in 2021, and the fight ended up in federal court. The DV-2021 mess is one of the clearest recent examples of how policy chaos punishes people who did everything by the book.
How did lottery winners end up in court?
The diversity visa program selects up to roughly 55,000 winners a year, but the law contains a brutal catch: visas must be issued by September 30 of the fiscal year, or the win expires forever. There is no rollover and no rain check.
DV-2021 winners were hit from two directions. First, a 2020 presidential proclamation had suspended entry for most immigrant visa categories, and consulates treated covered applicants as low priority. Second, even after that proclamation was revoked in early 2021, regional COVID entry bans and skeletal consular staffing meant many winners simply could not get an interview. The clock kept ticking anyway.
What did the courts actually do?
Winners sued in cases including Goodluck v. Biden and related litigation in the D.C. federal court. The core argument was straightforward: the State Department cannot refuse to process a category Congress created and then let the deadline destroy the applicants' rights. Judges largely agreed that sidelining diversity visa cases was unlawful, and courts took the unusual step of ordering thousands of DV-2021 visa numbers reserved past the September 30 deadline while the litigation played out.
Relief came slowly and unevenly. Court-ordered reserved visas were processed over the following years, but many winners never benefited, and similar fights repeated for DV-2020 and DV-2022 applicants.
Who was affected?
- Lottery winners abroad who could not get interviews before the deadline
- Winners from countries under regional COVID travel bans
- Families whose derivative spouses and children risked aging out or losing status together
- Applicants who had already paid fees, done medicals, and quit jobs in anticipation of moving
The rule-of-law lesson
You do not have to love the diversity lottery as policy to see the problem here. Many serious reformers, ourselves included, think a merit-based selection system would serve America better than a random draw. But as long as the lottery is the law Congress wrote, the executive branch has to run it faithfully. Agencies do not get to nullify a statute through slow-walking, and courts were right to say so. The same principle protects every legal applicant in every category: the government must follow its own rules.
What this means for you
If you play the diversity lottery today, learn from DV-2021. Enter every year you are eligible, since each win is a one-year, use-it-or-lose-it opportunity. If you are selected, move immediately: submit the DS-260 promptly, gather documents early, and watch your case number against the visa bulletin so you can act the moment you become current. Build a backup plan too, because with roughly 55,000 visas and millions of entrants, the lottery should never be your only strategy. Family, employment, student, and investor paths all reward preparation far more reliably than luck does.
Not sure which visa fits your situation? Take the free 2-minute Open visa quiz and get your match instantly.
Join the conversation